Archive for the ‘Didactic’ Category

Tradition(s) and repetition   1 comment

[Comments to a particular singer/songwriter’s mailing list, revised.]

I was chuckling at the various “if I never hear Pancho & Lefty again…” comments [on the mailing list], having remarked very recently that it’s on the short list of pop songs that I never tire of.  (The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald is another, despite its having been the background, on a boom box outside, while I took the SAT.  It’s also another where many people disagree with me.)

I grew up listening to, among other things, the traditional ballads (long story-songs) of Anglo–American folk:  Songs passed down through the generations, whose authors’ names are long since lost, but which are known by many people in a culture, and sung by professionals onstage and equally by people in the shower or at work or whatever.  One of my friends has a large hard drive on her computer entirely dedicated to versions of the Child Ballads.  My library is not so complete as that, but still contains dozens of examples from the collection with which Francis James Child blessed us.

Don’t get me wrong.  I also love an enormous amount of “singer/songwriter stuff,” the modern “folk” whose authors are known and which is performed for audiences, for pay.  But to my mind these are different genres, and modern “folk,” copyrighted and mostly sung by those who write it, is in the second category.  And of course it’s a spectrum, or rather several spectra across different dimensions.  There are singer/songwriters whose work is acoustic pop-with-guitars or maybe pianos, and singer/songwriters whose work is rooted in and almost indistinguishable from the ancient traditions,* and everything in between.  (To my mind, modern–ish political folk—Woody Guthrie, for instance, and his spiritual descendants—is either somewhere in the middle ground or orthogonal to this particular discussion, off on another plane.)   My taste tends very strongly toward the latter:  trad-style or neo–trad or whatever we choose to call it. And count me among those who can hear a good song over and over and over, performed by different artists or the same artist, in similar or wildly varying styles, and still enjoy them no less.  For whatever that’s worth.

* Stan Rogers used to introduce The Witch of the Westmorland (as Rogers spelled it, along with other edits—-the folk process in action!) as “a 300–year–old ballad written by my friend Archie Fisher,” and that’s the sort of thing I mean.

Posted 22 February 2013 by Folk Crossing in Didactic, Music: All

Introduction: Who Am I and What Am I Doing Here?   Leave a comment

Welcome to Folk Crossing!

I am an avid fan of several kinds of “folk” music, including (but not necessarily limited to) traditional British/Irish/American folk, some acoustic singer-songwriter music, various world/international traditions and fusions, blues, bluegrass, and filk.*  (On occasion, I also listen to early music, jazz, classical, rock, pop, country, or…you name it, I’ll give it a try, but may not write about it here.)  Often fans of one or two of these sub-genres ignore the rest.  During the year that I hosted a radio show at a university station, I was repeatedly told how unusual it was to have a show that played trad and singer/songwriter and “world” music.  Earlier, I had joined my then-local folk club, a venue that showcased all of these plus bluegrass; as a Lifetime Member, I could attend unlimited concerts–in my best month ever, that meant twenty!–and sampled much of the unknown but was stunned by how little overlap there was in the respective audiences.

Compartmentalizing has never appealed to me; rather, I am drawn to the interstitial, the crossover, the fusions.  Thus, Folk Crossing:  a mythopoeic crossroads where I imagine the genres meeting, conversing, exchanging ideas, sometimes walking in twos and threes along a new path together.   I want to explore any of these roads that appeal to me, and I invite all who share my tastes (or who think you might share them) to join the pilgrimage.

*Not a typo, though it started out as one!  Filk is the music sung specifically by and for the community of science-fiction and fantasy fans: often at conventions and other gatherings; usually about science and SFF themes; usually written by fans and professional SFF writers, some of whom are also professional musicians; sometimes poems from books set to music (e.g. the songs in J.R.R. Tolkien’s work), sometimes original, sometimes parodies of existing songs.

Notes and Guidelines
– I refer to it simply as “music,” but most of the time what I love is songs; the more lyrics-intense, the better.  I may discuss the formal music qualities, to the best of my untrained ability, but I’m more likely to talk about songs than instrumental music, and very likely to talk about the words as well as the tunes.
– Discussion is welcome, but I always reserve the right to moderate–so please, be polite, and keep it related to the music.
– Initially at least, the purpose here is “music evangelism” rather than criticism.  Which is to say, I’m not planning to review artists whose work doesn’t appeal to me personally, but primarily to provide info about what I consider the good stuff, as I do for friends.  Some of you won’t share my taste; most of you will share some likings but not everything.  Comments explaining what you personally don’t like about something are welcome here, when polite and appropriate; attacks on artists, genres, or fans thereof are not.  Recommendations of similar music, preferably with links to legal online examples, are enthusiastically solicited.
– And please do not get into the “what is folk music” debate, which I’ve seen causing havoc in discussion groups.   “It’s only folk if  people learn it from one another, without recordings!” “It’s only folk if nobody gets paid for it!”  “It’s only folk if we don’t know who wrote it!”  NO.   I am sympathetic to some of these views, but will not specify which because that’s not the purpose of this blog–except to say that highly professional, produced, popular-radio songs are generally not within “folk” as I understand it, and are unlikely to be discussed here.

On the other hand, the variously-cited remark, “All music is folk, I never heard [whatever animal] sing it,” is also unwelcome.   For this, I’ll be autocratic:  Posts that violate the guidelines will be hidden at my sole discretion, and especially if I think the conversation is getting derailed.

Walk along with me, and I will walk with you/On the paths of joy and paths of sorrow too/Walk along with, walk along with, walk along with, walk along with me and I will walk with you.

And if our pathways meet but for a little while/We’ll still have time to share a word, a song, a smile…

And at our destination we may meet again/Then I’ll smile and say, “It’s good to see you, friend…”

— Eileen McGann, “I See My Journey”

Posted 12 February 2013 by Folk Crossing in Didactic, Music: All